Tyler ([info]blinovitch) wrote,
@ 2008-04-19 18:49:00
Previous Entry  Add to memories!  Tell a Friend!  Next Entry
Doctor Who: Planet of the Ood
I have really mixed feeling about this episode.

First off, I liked the Ood when we met them back in The Impossible Satan Planet Pit. I figured they'd been enslaved and there was an uprising on the way, so I'm glad we got to see it.

But there was some really weird stuff going on in this episode. Why were two of the people complicit in the subjugation of a species members of historically oppressed ethnicities themselves? Kess, a black man, was a literal whip-cracking overseer, while Solana, the Indian woman, was a heartless PR flak. I want to know if that was intention on the production team's part. The way the camera lingered on those characters at key points, and the nature of Commander Kess' death, makes me think it was meant to be ironic commentary.

Hooray for the Friend of the Ood mole. That was neat, but did he really have to die?

Donna gets more points for maturity and general competence. I think I like her better than Martha or Rose at this point.

Next week, Martha Jones and Sontarans. Meh.


(Post a new comment)


[info]beebleblog
2008-04-20 10:33 am UTC (link)
Yeah, there were some strangely un-subtle moments and imagery that perhaps were there for the young'uns.

In general Britain seems both more and less enlightened about race issues, if you kind of get my meaning.


(Reply to this)


[info]indefatigable42
2008-04-21 04:01 am UTC (link)
Why were two of the people complicit in the subjugation of a species members of historically oppressed ethnicities themselves?

I noticed that myself, and I almost feel like it works in context. The historical period that we think of when we see a black man acting as a cruel slaver is, to them, a span of a few hundred years that happened two millenia ago. Maybe it's something they learn about in history class and promptly forget. It works as a science fiction plot because it points out to me that even when humans no longer care about the colours of their own skin, someone always finds someone to oppress.

Maybe it's a bit tactless for white writers and producers to tell such a story, but I'm not about to go around telling people not to write the stories they want to write, if they think they have something important to say.

(Reply to this)(Thread)


[info]blinovitch
2008-04-22 02:36 am UTC (link)
Maybe it's a bit tactless for white writers and producers to tell such a story, but I'm not about to go around telling people not to write the stories they want to write, if they think they have something important to say.

I agree with that. I just don't think there was any punchline considering the amount of set-up they put into it. Like, "Hey, here are these historically oppressed minorities who are now doing the oppressing, thus showing it's humanity in general that are a bunch of dicks and not a characteristic of one particular culture. And then they die."

I wanted more pay-off than that.

(Reply to this)(Parent)


Create an Account
Forgot your login?
Login w/ OpenID
English • Español • Deutsch • Русский…